Back Office BeatSubscribe

Published by J9 Systems. What's new in business tech, and what it means for yours.

From the brief of Tuesday, November 17, 2026 · No. 29

From the daily brief · Policy

11th Circuit: FL, GA, AL workers can sue over 401(k) plans without plan appeals first

If you sponsor a 401(k) and have staff in Florida, Georgia or Alabama, an employee who suspects bad fees can now go straight to federal court.

By Carter Josephson · · 2 min read

What happened

On Oct. 13 the full 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled unanimously in Bolton v. Inland Fresh Seafood that ERISA does not require employees to exhaust a plan's internal remedies before suing over statutory claims, including breach of fiduciary duty. The court overruled its own 1985 Mason precedent, and the Labor Department welcomed the decision on Nov. 16.

What it means for a 10-to-50-person business

This is not a new rule, and it changes nothing your plan must file or do. It changes litigation risk. In Florida, Georgia and Alabama, an employee who reasonably suspects a fiduciary breach, such as excessive fees, no longer has to go through the plan's internal claims process first. Take a 25-person plumbing company in Jacksonville with a 401(k) holding an assumed $1.5 million. Suppose all-in fees run 1.2%, or $18,000 a year, and comparable small plans pay 0.8%, or $12,000. Participants would be paying an extra $6,000 a year. The owner, as plan sponsor, is usually a fiduciary. A recent fee benchmark is the document that shows you checked. Fiduciary liability insurance pays defense costs. Assume it costs $1,000 to $2,500 a year for a $1 million limit. The ERISA fidelity bond you are already required to carry does not cover those costs. Employers with no retirement or other ERISA plan can ignore this. Plans with no participants in those three states see less direct change. The ruling covers statutory claims such as fiduciary breach; denied-benefit claims still normally go through the plan's appeals first.

What to do
Ask your vendor

This month, email your 401(k) provider or third-party administrator for the plan's most recent fee benchmarking report, and ask your insurance broker to confirm in writing whether you carry fiduciary liability coverage, separate from the ERISA fidelity bond, and at what limit.

What it costs
What it costs
Requesting fee benchmark from provider/TPA
assume $0 fee; 1 hr owner time (≈ $75 at $75/hr)
Broker call to confirm or quote fiduciary liability, assume $1M limit
1 hr; assume $1,000–$2,500/yr if you need to buy it
Fee gap example, $1.5M plan at 1.2% vs 0.8%
$6,000/yr paid by employees
Doing nothing
$0 now; an employee in FL, GA or AL can sue without first using the plan's claims process, and uninsured defense costs fall on the business
Sources
media.ca11.uscourts.gov (primary) · DOL release: Labor Department applauds 11th Circuit decision · DOL EBSA: Fiduciary responsibilities

Questions owners ask

Is this a new Labor Department rule?

No. It is a court decision that removes a procedural step before employees can sue. Your plan's filing, disclosure and fee obligations are unchanged.

Does it apply outside Florida, Georgia and Alabama?

The decision binds federal courts in the 11th Circuit, which covers those three states. Other circuits set their own rules, and the release excerpt does not address them.

Isn't my ERISA bond the same as fiduciary insurance?

No. The fidelity bond required by ERISA protects the plan against theft or fraud by people who handle plan money. Fiduciary liability insurance covers the fiduciaries, often the owner, for claims of breach, including defense costs.

Three to five of these, every weekday morning.

Related